Energy-inefficient homes: French MPs scrap rental bans by just six votes
Against the government's advice, MPs on Tuesday evening adopted by 108 votes to 102 a far-right RN amendment that removes the bans on renting out homes with the worst energy ratings (DPE). The disputed vote is not final.

A thunderclap in the housing debate. On the evening of Tuesday 17 November, the National Assembly adopted by 108 votes to 102 an amendment from the Rassemblement national that lifts the bans on renting out so-called thermal sieves, homes rated among the worst under France's energy performance diagnosis (DPE).
Tabled by Frédéric Falcon, an RN MP for the Aude department, amendment no. 85 passed with the support of the conservative Droite républicaine group and against the government's advice. It strips out most of Article 160 of the 2021 Climate and Resilience law, which set the timetable for the bans.
The government only wanted more flexibility
That timetable had three stages: G-rated homes barred from the rental market since 2025, F-rated homes from 2028 and E-rated homes from 2034. The housing revival and decentralisation bill, already passed by the Senate in July, did not scrap those rules. Its Article 6 allowed owners to keep renting out an F or G home if they committed to renovation work: three years for a house, five years in a co-owned building. It also offered a way out when works prove impossible, for instance if co-owners refuse them.
According to the government, this flexibility would keep or bring back 650,000 to 700,000 homes on the market by 2028, LCP reports. Housing minister Vincent Jeanbrun said he wanted to restore flexibility and time while keeping renovation on course. After the vote, his office distanced itself, telling Batiweb that the government proposes and Parliament decides, and that the outcome reflected neither the government's nor the minister's position.
A disputed vote
The result hung by a thread. According to Batiweb, four MPs later reported voting by mistake: three meant to vote against, a fourth to abstain. With those corrections, the amendment would have failed by 105 to 104. But the Assembly's rules forbid changing a vote once the ballot has closed, so the adoption stands.
RN cheers, tenant advocates fume
Frédéric Falcon hailed the scrapping of the DPE constraints as no small feat, denouncing what he called carnage on the rental market.
On the left, France Insoumise MP Anaïs Belouassa-Cherifi called it a major step backwards for every tenant in the country. Manuel Domergue, research director at the Fondation pour le logement, described it as a disaster for tenants and called for a new vote. The Rénovons collective, which brings together energy renovation players, sees it as a gift to the wealthiest.
What happens next
Nothing changes yet: the DPE-based bans remain in force until the law is amended. The government or any MP can request a second deliberation before the explanations of vote on the whole bill. The minister's office has not said whether it will. The formal vote on the bill is scheduled for Tuesday 24 November. The text must then go to a joint committee of seven MPs and seven senators, who will try to agree on a common version.


