Zecler trial: three police officers convicted, court finds racist motive
Shortly after 10 p.m. on Friday, 20 November, the Paris criminal court sentenced the three officers tried over the 2020 beating of music producer Michel Zecler to five years in prison, with one to two years to be served. It found a racist aggravating circumstance and banned them from policing for life.

The verdict came late in the evening. After more than eleven hours of deliberation, the Paris criminal court resumed its sitting at 10:02 p.m. on Friday, 20 November, according to Outre-mer La 1ère. The three police officers accused of beating Michel Zecler, a Black music producer, in November 2020 were found guilty. And the court ruled that the violence was racially motivated.
All three received five-year prison sentences, with different suspended portions:
- Aurélien Lapersonne: five years, three of them suspended, meaning two years to serve. He was also convicted of unlawful entry into a home;
- Philippe Tondeux: five years, three and a half suspended, meaning eighteen months to serve;
- Pierre Plantier: five years, four suspended, meaning one year to serve, which he may serve with an electronic tag.
The three men are permanently banned from working as police officers, with immediate effect, and barred from public office for five years, La 1ère reported. Aurélien Lapersonne and Philippe Tondeux are subject to a deferred committal order: they were not jailed on the spot but will be within the coming weeks, and within four months at most.
Racism upheld, against the investigating judges
This is the most striking part of the ruling. The investigating judges had dropped the racist aggravating circumstance for lack of evidence. The court reinstated it. Michel Zecler has always said he was called a racial slur, which the officers flatly denied.
The judges relied on the consistency of the producer's account, AFP reported via France 24. He gave the same version to the Black officer who handcuffed him, then at the police station, on the way to hospital and to his relatives. By contrast, the false arrest report, disproved by CCTV footage, and statements the court found insincere undermined the defendants' denials.
The three officers were convicted of aggravated assault and forgery of a public document. They faced up to fifteen years in prison.
Below the prosecution's demands
The court stopped short of what the prosecution sought. On Thursday, the advocate general had asked for four to six years behind bars: six for Lapersonne, five for Tondeux, four for Plantier. The judges took into account the defendants' admissions, the apologies they made in court, their social integration and their clean records.
Before the court withdrew, Philippe Tondeux apologised again, saying he also wanted to apologise to the justice system and for the image of the police he had given, according to La 1ère.
A video that changed everything
The events date back to 21 November 2020, during lockdown. Stopped outside his studio in Paris's 17th arrondissement for not wearing a mask, Michel Zecler was beaten in the building's entrance. A tear gas grenade was thrown inside. The officers' report accused him of resisting arrest. CCTV footage published by Loopsider showed otherwise. In court, one defendant admitted the report was false from start to finish.
Without the videos, he would not be standing before the court as a victim, Michel Zecler had said, according to Euronews. His lawyer, Serge Money, welcomed the verdict, saying justice had been done.
What next?
The three officers have ten days to appeal. If they do, the case would be retried before another court. The verdict came one day short of the sixth anniversary of the beating.


