Remarks on Muslims: Michel Houellebecq placed under formal investigation in Nanterre
The writer was placed under formal investigation on Tuesday 10 November for complicity in inciting discrimination, hatred or violence. At issue: an interview with Michel Onfray published in late 2022 in the magazine Front populaire.

Four years after the uproar, the courts have caught up with Michel Houellebecq. The author of Submission was placed under formal investigation on Tuesday 10 November by an investigating judge at the Nanterre court, west of Paris, for complicity in inciting discrimination, hatred or violence, according to a source close to the case quoted by AFP. The news was first reported by Le Figaro.
The writer remains presumed innocent. Being placed under formal investigation means the judge believes there is serious or consistent evidence, but it does not decide whether there will be a trial, let alone a conviction.
An interview with Michel Onfray
The case concerns remarks published in late November 2022 in Front populaire, the magazine of philosopher Michel Onfray, during a long conversation between the two men. Michel Houellebecq described Muslims as a threat to the safety of "native" French people. He argued that what the latter wanted was not for Muslims to assimilate, but for them to stop robbing and attacking them, or else leave.
He also predicted future "reverse Bataclans" targeting Muslims, a reference to the jihadist attacks of 13 November 2015.
A complaint filed in 2023
The Union of Mosques of France (UMF) filed a complaint in January 2023 with the Nanterre court. It targeted the writer, as well as Michel Onfray and Stéphane Simon, the director of Front populaire.
The Grand Mosque of Paris, for its part, dropped its own action. Its rector, Chems-eddine Hafiz, met the novelist in January 2023 and accepted the regrets he expressed then. In Quelques mois dans ma vie, octobre 2022-mars 2023, Michel Houellebecq returned to the affair, calling his wording clumsy and saying he was a victim of his own naivety.
The defence pushes back
His lawyers, Thibault de Montbrial and Louis Cailliez, dispute the offence. In their view, the remarks contain no exhortation, not even an implicit one. They deplore the judicialisation of intellectual debate and argue the controversy should have ended after the meeting with the rector.
On the other side, the UMF's lawyer, Najwa El Haïté, defended the proceedings. Free speech is fundamental but cannot justify everything, she said, arguing that incitement to hatred is not part of the battle of ideas, while recalling the presumption of innocence.
What next?
The investigation continues. No closing date and no referral to a criminal court have been announced. What happens to Michel Onfray and Stéphane Simon, also named in the complaint, has not been specified at this stage.


